 |
| By GR Stocks on Unsplash |
Today the European Commission announced their proposal to modernise ADR rules in Europe, in line with the digitalisation agenda (New measures to simplify the resolution of disputes out of court and boost consumer rights). This follows from the 2023 Consumer scoreboard results showing continued low numbers of consumers proceeding with enforcing their rights (1/4 of consumers experiences a significant consumer problem, but 1/3 of them does not complain for reasons related to time, cost and low confidence). The key points of the new plan to address these issues are:
- Abolition of ODR (see for the proposal for a new regulation repealing ODR here) - currently the ODR platform facilitates ca 200 cases per year in the EU, which the Commission perceives as not justifying the costs of keeping this platform open and costs of business having to comply with ODR Regulation obligations (e.g. providing a link to ODR platform and assuring appropriate communication channels). The plan is to replace the ODR platform with 'user-friendly digital tools' assisting consumers in choosing a redress option.
- Broadening of the scope of ADR - it will no longer be necessary that a dispute stems from a concluded contract between the parties. This will allow encompassing all EU consumer law, incl. pre-contractual issues especially pertinent to online environment, e.g. misleading advertising and deceptive design, access to services and unjustified geoblocking. It aims also to start facilitating procedures against non-EU traders (although they as well would need to voluntarily join the scheme).
- Providing for additional consumer advice in accessing and during ADR process - to be delivered by designed bodies, e.g. European Consumer Centres Network. This could consist of translation, explanation of consumer rights, ADR procedures, etc.
- Removing some of the burdens for traders to encourage their uptake of ADR participation - e.g. reducing information obligations for traders. Additionally, ADR entities will ask traders whether they intend to participate in ADR when a consumer raises a complaint, which traders will need to answer in 20 days. This is aimed at prompting traders to (re-)consider their ADR participation.
- Removing some of the burdens and costs for ADR entities - e.g. reducing their reporting obligations (from every year to every 2 years, and requiring a more condensed report); facilitating bundling of cases with similar elements (although only upon consent of relevant consumers).
- Improving transparency - e.g. when a dispute is resolved through automated means, parties may request review by a natural person.
Additionally, the European Commission recommends online marketplaces to align their dispute resolution systems to European ADR principles, especially effectiveness, fairness, independence, expertise, impartiality, and transparency. See here for the Recommendation on quality requirements for dispute resolution procedures offered by online marketplaces and Union trade associations C(2023) 7019 final.
