Tuesday, 15 November 2016

If it talks like a seller... - CJEU in Wathelet (C-149/15)

Last week the CJEU also issued a judgement in the Wathelet case (C-149/15) concerning interpretation of the Consumer Sales Directive (CSD) with regard to a sale of a second-hand vehicle in Belgium.

Ms Wathelet has purchased a second-hand vehicle for 4.000 Euro as a consumer from a professional garage and did not obtain any receipt, proof of payment or a sales invoice for this purchase. The garage paid for the roadworthiness test, while Ms Wathelet paid for the registration of the vehicle. The car has promptly broke down, before the consumer received the invoice for the purchase. The garage found that the fault was with the engine and charged Ms Wathelet for 2.000 Euro for its repair. She has refused to pay this repair price, claiming that the garage as the seller of the vehicle was responsible for this fault. At this point, Ms Wathelet was informed that the garage has never owned the car and has sold it on behalf of Ms Donckels, another consumer. Ms Donckels has, however, never received the full purchase price, as the garage withheld 800 Euro to credit repairs that have been conducted on the vehicle. The garage sent then a letter to Ms Wathelet, confirming its capacity as an intermediary, stating that the engine failure is an 'ordinary risk' when buying a second-hand car from another consumer, and attached an invoice for the purchase price of 4.000 Euro on which it was handwritten that Ms Donckels was the seller. The invoice only had the signature of Ms Donckels. The garage refused to return the car until the repair price of 2.000 Euro is paid in full and brought proceedings against Ms Wathelet for payment of this invoice. Ms Wathelet counter-claimed demanding termination of the contract of sale and damages.


The Court of Appeal in Liege, Belgium, finds that there is strong evidence that Ms Wathelet was never informed that it was a private sale and, therefore, asks the CJEU whether the notion of a 'seller' encompasses not only professional traders who transfer ownership of consumer goods to consumers, but also traders acting as intermediaries for private parties, and whether the answer would differ depending on whether they are remunerated for their services and whether the consumer was informed of the fact that the sale was a C2C sale.

The CJEU first determines that the notion of the seller should be interpreted autonomously for the purposes of the Consumer Sales Directive, considering its objectives. The notion does not cover intermediaries (par. 33), however, that does not mean that it could not cover traders who act as intermediaries (regardless of whether they are remunerated for their services - see par. 43) but present themselves as professional sellers to consumers, giving consumers false impression that they are concluding a B2C contract (par. 34). The CJEU states that literal interpretation of art. 1(2)(c) of CSD does not prevent such an interpretation, teleological arguments - supporting high level of consumer protection - strengthen it (par. 35-36). It is essential for consumers to know the identity of the seller, and whether it is a professional party, as they will only have remedies for non-conformity of the purchased goods from a professional seller under CSD (par. 37). The consumer should have, therefore, been informed that the owner was a private individual, eliminating information imbalance between the parties. (par. 39-40)

"Therefore, in circumstances such as those at issue in the main proceedings, in which the consumer can easily be misled in the light of the conditions in which the sale is carried out, it is necessary to afford the latter enhanced protection. Therefore, the seller’s liability, in accordance with Directive 1999/44, must be capable of being imposed on an intermediary who, by addressing the consumer, creates a likelihood of confusion in the mind of the latter, leading him to believe in its capacity as owner of the goods sold." (par. 41)

"...The degree of participation and the amount of effort employed by the intermediary in the sale, the circumstances in which the goods were presented to the consumer and the latter’s behaviour may, in particular, be relevant in that regard in order to determine whether the consumer could have understood that the intermediary was acting on behalf of a private individual." (par. 44)

3 comments:

  1. We specialized in Bank Guarantee {BG}, Standby Letter of Credit {SBLC}, Medium Term Notes {MTN}, Confirmable Bank Draft {CBD} as well as other financial instruments issued from AAA Rated bank such as HSBC Bank Hong Kong, HSBC Bank London, Deutsche Bank AG Frankfurt, Barclays Bank , Standard Chartered Bank and others on lease at the lowest available rates depending on the face value of the instrument needed.

    We deliver with time and precision as sethforth in the agreement. Our terms and Conditions are reasonable, below is our instrument description.

    The procedure is very simple; the instrument will be reserved on euro clear to be verified by your bank, after verification an arrangement will be made for necessary bank documents and stock testing expenses, the cost of the Bank Guarantee will be paid after the delivery of the MT760.

    Below is our instrument description.

    DESCRIPTION OF INSTRUMENT:
    Instrument: Bank Guarantee (BG/SBLC).
    Total Face Value: Minimum of 1M Eur/USD (One Million Eur/USD) to Maximum of 5B Euro/USD(Five Billion Eur/USD).

    Issuing Bank: HSBC London, Barclays Bank, Deutsche Bank Frankfurt, Hong Kong, Any AA rated Bank in Europe or any Top 25 WEB.

    Age: One Year, One Day
    Leasing Price: 5% of Face Value plus 2% commission fees to brokers.
    Delivery: Bank to Bank SWIFT.
    Payment: MT-760.
    Hard Copy: Bonded Courier within 7 banking days.

    All relevant business information will be provided upon request plus our terms and procedures: If you are interested please contact me for us to proceed further

    Regards

    Devdutt Vyas
    Email: devdutt_vyas@outlook.com
    devdutt.vyas2016@gmail.com
    Skype: devdutt.vyas

    ReplyDelete
  2. HOW EDWARD LOAN COMPANY GRANTED ME A BUSINESS LOAN {Jonesloanfinance@yahoo.com} or Text +1(307) 241-3712

    Hello everyone, I am Oliver Johnson Moore from Zurich Switzerland and want to use this medium to express gratitude to EDWARD JONES for fulfilling his promise by granting me a loan, i was stuck in a financial situation and needed to refinance and pay my bills as well as start up a Business. I tried seeking for loans from various loan firms both private and corporate organisations but never succeeded and most banks declined my credit request. But as God would have it, i was introduced by a friend named Lisa Rice to EDWARD JONES LOAN COMPANY and undergone the due process of obtaining a loan from the company, to my greatest surprise within 28hrs just like my friend Lisa, i was also granted a loan of $387,000.00; So my advise to everyone who desires a loan, "if you must contact any firm with reference to securing a loan online with low interest rate of 2% and better repayment plans/schedule, please contact EDWARD JONES LOAN COMPANY. Besides, he doesn't know that am doing this but due to the joy in me, i'm so happy and wish to let people know more about this great company whom truly give out loans, it is my prayer that GOD should bless them more as they put smiles on peoples faces. You can contact them via email on {Jonesloanfinance@yahoo.com} or Text +1(307) 241-3712

    ReplyDelete
  3. UEFA Champions League - Final Tickets

    REAL MADRID VS JUVENTUS

    Principality Stadium (Millennium Stadium), Cardiff, United Kingdom
    Saturday, June 03 2017 19:45


    In this year's Champions League Final we'll see two football dynamos facing it off until the last minute - what a match it will be! The tension's building and you want to be part of it. Look no further and secure your Champions League Final tickets right here right now. 1st Stop Ticketing is Europe's leading ticket exchange and the safest marketplace for you and your Champions League tickets. Have a browse on our Champions League Final 2017 tickets below and grab them fast!


    Section: Category 1

    Section: Cardiff Castle

    Section: Category 1 | Row L30

    Section: Category 1 | Row U9

    Section: Category 1 | Row U10

    Section: VIP Gold

    Contact us for price

    E-mail : booking@1ststopticketing.com

    Contact Person: MR TREVOR ROY SIMPSON

    ReplyDelete